In honor of Tax Day, I saw a list on JD Supra of “10 arguments against paying taxes” (as seen on the IRS website and written in the blog, Mental Floss). “Most of these arguments have gone to the courts numerous times and found to be without merit. So if you don’t want to pay your taxes, you’ll have to dream up something more creative than these 10 examples.” Enjoy!
1. Taxes are “voluntary”
This argument comes from a misunderstanding of the word “voluntary,” which appears in a few tax-related sources, including the instructions that come with your 1040 tax form. Unfortunately, the legal definition of the word “voluntary” in this case refers to the process by which taxpayers report and pay taxes on voluntarily reported income, as opposed to a system where the government just tells you what to pay and you fork it over. And don’t think that you can be tricky and say that filing a tax return might be mandatory but paying the taxes is voluntary. They’ve already thought of that one, too.
2. Compensation is not income
Here’s the argument: If I work for compensation, then I’m not actually profiting. I’m just bartering my time for money, which is a zero-sum transaction, and, consequently, I have no gain or profit that can be legally taxed. This can be misconstrued as an “exchange” and not actually income. The IRS rebuttal: Clever, but not convincing.
3. Taxes in America aren’t for Americans
Apparently there’s a sentence or two in the tax code (which is over 50,000 pages, by the way) that discriminates between U.S. and non-U.S. source income. It’s just a small point explained so that folks don’t pay double taxes if they happen to have income from multiple countries. A few individuals have plucked this one little idea and claimed that no taxes are due on income earned in America by Americans. Only aliens have to pay. The IRS rebuttal: Read the other 49,999 pages and get back to us.
4. Money isn’t legal tender
Some folks are a little peeved that they can’t take a couple of Benjamins into their local banks and exchange them for equal amounts of silver or gold. They therefore claim that the income they earn paid in such “worthless” tender cannot be taxed, as it inherently has no value. Truth is, they’ve got nothing to be peeved about. Article I, Section 10 of the Constitution says that the states cannot declare anything as legal tender other than gold and silver, but imposes no such limits on the Congress.
Read the rest of the arguments by clicking here.
- Tax bills are lower this year, but they will incre...
- Tax Bills Won’t Rise for Parents Who Keep Older Ki...
- Government Jobs Not So Cushy
- More Than a Million May Lose Jobless Aid Due to De...
- New Jobless Claims Drop By 11,000
- Latest Good Reads
- 5 Lies The Big Banks Keep Telling Us
- Tax credit end not deterring US homebuyers
- Hawaii Governor Vetoes Oil Tax and Other Bills
- Still no Wall Street bill debate in Senate
- Economists: The Stimulus Didn't Help
- Home Prices in Feb Showed First Annual Gain in 3 Y...
- Obama Tells Panel on Federal Debt to Consider All ...
- Paring Back So You Can Retire Comfortably
- Spring Cleaning for your Finances
- Questions for the Tax Lady: April 26th, 2010
- Sales of New Homes Soar With Help of Tax Credit
- Client Confidentiality: an Important Aspect of Leg...
- More American Expatriates Give Up Citizenship
- Bank Tax Tops G20 Meeting Agenda
- 4 Million Will Pay Health Care Penalty
- Low Income Taxpayer Clinic Grant Recipients Announ...
- Family Swindled By Madoff Fights $61 Million IRS B...
- Cost-Saving Moving Tips
- Happy Earth Day!
- Obama to Wall Street: 'Join Us' In Reform
- Existing U.S. Home Sales Climb to 5.35 Million Rat...
- How to Make Next Tax Season Less Stressful by Prep...
- Latest Good Reads
- Small Businesses Get a Boost from Nonprofit Lender...
- Pistons Rick Mahorn files for bankruptcy
- 10 Tax Breaks for the Home, Room by Room
- Wells Fargo Earns $2.4B, Says Credit Is Improving
- No Job For Years and Still Looking
- Summertime, When The Livin' Is Pricey
- 10 Tax Preparers Plead Guilty of IRS Fraud
- 6 Biggest Mistakes Homebuyers Make
- Hobbies and Small Businesses
- Senate Considers Proposal to Curb Foreign-Tax Cred...
- IRS Announces New Advisory Council Members
- GM to Announce It Will Pay Back Government Loans S...
- What to do if you Missed the Tax Deadline
- Questions for the Tax Lady: April 19th, 2010
- California Jobless Rate Swells to 12.6 Percent
- OECD Crackdown on Tax Havens Seen Lacking Teeth
- How to Avoid Giving Uncle Sam a Free Loan
- Tea-Party Activists Stage Tax-Day Rallies
- 5 Lessons from the Obamas’ Tax Return
- Home Buyer Tax Credits Spark IRS Audits
- 10 Arguments Against Paying Taxes (that will not w...
- What’s in a Nickname? The Origins of MLB Team Nam...
- IRS Spending More Time Auditing Small Businesses
- What a Recession Means for Your Business
- Tax Day Freebies!
- Last Minute Tax Tips on the Today Show
- Tax Day 2010: How the Income Tax Put Al Capone beh...
- IRS Data Show Tax Agency Audits Big Firms Less Oft...
- My Appearance on FOX Business Yesterday
- Taxes: Are You Crossing the Line?
- Haiti Relief Workers Qualify for Combat Zone Exten...
- Washington Lawmakers OK $1-Per-Pack Cigarette Tax ...
- 9 Very Last Minute Tax Preparation Tips
- Can the U.S. learn from New Zealand when it comes ...
- 5 Least Tax-Friendly States to Live In
- Tax Resolution Programs
- Nation's Soaring Deficit Calls for Painful Choices...
- No More Taxes on Short Sales, Foreclosures
- Government Goes High-Tech to Catch Tax Offenders
- Questions for the Tax Lady: April 12th, 2010
- Obama Election-Year Jobs Agenda Stalls in Congress...
- US Tax Bite Smaller than Other Nations'
- Poll: More Americans Say Their Taxes Fair
- Avoid Common Mistakes When Filing Your Tax Return
- CDC: States Not Putting Cigarette Tax Funds Into E...
- Understanding The U.S. Tax Withholding System
- More Than 200,000 Jobless Counting On An Extension...
- Big Brother is Watching: IRS Uses Social Media Sit...
- The Joy of Tax
- Top 10 FAQs About IRS Refunds
- 8 Do's and Don'ts For Your 401k
- Cigarette Tax Bump in 15 States Lifts U.S. Fees to...
- What You Can Learn From Your Tax Return
- 2 Years After Tax Law, Michigan's Making Movies
- Top Ten List Of Things To Know About Making Federa...
- Property Tax Rebellion Brewing After Real Estate C...
- Few Will Use Tax Refund to Indulge: Poll
- Are You Finding Difficulty Coping During Tax Time?...
- 3 Smart Ways You Can Fight Rising Taxes
- Charities and Deductions
- IRS Launches New Global Program to Target High Wea...
- Feeling Blue About Pink-Slip Taxes
- Tax Tips for 2010
- The Pros and Cons of Soda Taxes
- Questions for the Tax Lady: April 5th, 2010
- Californians get Improved $10,000 Home Buyer Tax C...
- 5 Myths About your Taxes
- Three New Issues to be Addressed by IRS Industry I...
- Reminders for Last-Minute Tax Filers
- March Unemployment Rate Unchanged At 9.7%
- FactCheck.org: IRS Will Not Need to Hire 16,500 N...
- ▼ April (104)
- ► 2009 (987)
- ► 2008 (410)
- ► 2007 (191)